The New Yorker Animates its Cartoons

by Art Fag City on March 20, 2007 · 4 comments Reviews

What’s with the animated cartoons on The New Yorker’s new website? I’m embarrassed just sitting in front of my computer watching those things. A dog retells a mindless conversation about the Middle East, explaining he could only respond with “woof”, filming an empty scooter, a man tells his wife they can blue screen the kids in later, a guy writes on the wall above the suggestion box, and an attendant informs him that his ideas should go in the box. These are the punchlines.

I’m not usually a huge fan of the cartoons in the first place, though occasionally they publish a really good one, but why animate something that doesn’t need it? Of course, the other question lies in who animates these things – the cartoonists, or some tech flunky? Either way it’s hard to imagine a greater waste of money.

{ 4 comments }

Timothy Buckwalter March 21, 2007 at 7:36 pm

yeah, I’m with you on this one.

To me, what is often funny about The New Yorker cartoons is their simpleness and the speedy delivery of a punchline. These animated things are barely animated, take far too long and the faux-chamber music soundtrack only reinforces the already stodgey and dull image of The New Yorker. Plus it looks like the washes were done with a watercolor set bought at Rexall Drugs.

Timothy Buckwalter March 21, 2007 at 7:36 pm

yeah, I’m with you on this one.

To me, what is often funny about The New Yorker cartoons is their simpleness and the speedy delivery of a punchline. These animated things are barely animated, take far too long and the faux-chamber music soundtrack only reinforces the already stodgey and dull image of The New Yorker. Plus it looks like the washes were done with a watercolor set bought at Rexall Drugs.

Timothy Buckwalter March 21, 2007 at 7:36 pm

yeah, I’m with you on this one.

To me, what is often funny about The New Yorker cartoons is their simpleness and the speedy delivery of a punchline. These animated things are barely animated, take far too long and the faux-chamber music soundtrack only reinforces the already stodgey and dull image of The New Yorker. Plus it looks like the washes were done with a watercolor set bought at Rexall Drugs.

Timothy Buckwalter March 21, 2007 at 3:36 pm

yeah, I’m with you on this one.

To me, what is often funny about The New Yorker cartoons is their simpleness and the speedy delivery of a punchline. These animated things are barely animated, take far too long and the faux-chamber music soundtrack only reinforces the already stodgey and dull image of The New Yorker. Plus it looks like the washes were done with a watercolor set bought at Rexall Drugs.

Comments on this entry are closed.

Previous post:

Next post: